
Title disputes arise when there are questions or opposing claims about a real estate property. Since a clear property title is crucial to a successful transaction, these disputes can delay or even prevent a real estate sale, refinance, or transfer of ownership. Understanding how title disputes occur and how they are resolved can help you navigate this challenge should you encounter it.
What Is a Title Dispute?
A title dispute is legal uncertainty or conflict regarding property ownership or the rights to use a property. Such issues are typically identified during a title search (conducted before closing), but they can also surface days, weeks, or years after settlement. Regardless of when they occur, unresolved title issues can prevent a clear transfer of ownership and can pose financial and legal risks for the homeowner.
Common Causes of Title Disputes
Title disputes stem from a wide range of issues, which can originate years or even decades earlier. Some of the more common include title defects, such as:
- Errors in public records – These can involve clerical mistakes, misspellings, incorrect legal descriptions, or filing errors when recording legal documents in city or county records. While usually unintentional, they can create inconsistencies that call property ownership into question.
- Unknown liens or unpaid debts – Encumbrances such as tax liens, mechanic’s liens, or judgments against a previous homeowner can remain attached to a property if they were never satisfied or recorded as released.
- Boundary and survey disputes – Inconsistent surveys or unclear property boundaries can lead to disputes with neighboring property owners or others with ownership interests concerning factors like land use, access, or encroachments.
- Missing or undisclosed heirs – When a property is inherited, not all heirs may be properly identified or notified. A previously unknown heir can later come forward and assert a legal claim to the property.
- Forgery or fraud – Factors such as forged signatures, fraudulent deeds or other documents, or identity theft can nullify previous ownership transfers and lead to legal disputes.
- Improperly executed documents – Legal documents like deeds, wills, or powers of attorney that were signed without proper legal authority or not processed correctly can render a real estate transaction invalid.
How Are Title Disputes Discovered?
Most title disputes are identified during a title search, which is the process of reviewing public records to confirm a property’s ownership history and detect potential title issues. In some cases, however, title issues do not surface until after closing — particularly if they’re beyond the scope of a standard title search.
How Are Title Disputes Resolved?
The process for resolving title disputes largely depends on the nature and complexity of the issue. Common approaches include:
- Clerical error correction – Minor issues, such as misspellings or recording errors, can often be resolved by filing corrective documents with the appropriate recording office.
- Lien payment or release – Outstanding liens are often resolved by satisfying the debt, negotiating a settlement, or obtaining and recording a lien release. When identified before closing, liens are typically paid and cleared as part of the settlement process. If a lien is discovered after closing, it may be resolved with the help of owner’s title insurance (depending on the coverage).
- Obtaining affidavits or indemnifications – Affidavits from previous owners or other parties with an ownership stake in the property may be used to clarify key facts, document intent, or address gaps in ownership history.
- Legal title actions – In some cases, resolving title disputes may require legal action. One common approach is a quiet title lawsuit, where the court determines rightful ownership and clears competing claims.
- Title insurance coverage – If a covered title defect arises after closing, title insurance can help cover legal costs and financial losses associated with defending ownership rights.
Are Title Disputes Preventable?
While it’s not always possible to prevent title disputes, steps taken during the transaction process help reduce the risk of complications. A title search, typically performed by the title company conducting the closing, helps identify potential title defects. When issues are found, they’re often resolved before closing to help reduce the risk of future disputes.
Purchasing an owner’s title insurance policy also helps protect your financial and legal interests should disputes or other defects arise after closing.
To learn more about title disputes and how they are resolved, contact the team at Linear Title & Escrow.








